Repairs vs Credits Decision Guide

    When to fix issues yourself versus offering buyers credit.

    After a buyer's inspection, you'll negotiate repairs. Here's how to decide what to do.

    Make Repairs When:

    Safety Issues

    • Electrical hazards
    • Gas leaks
    • Structural concerns
    • Mold remediation

    Quick Fixes

    • Items a handyman handles in a day
    • Cost is known and predictable
    • Quality won't be questioned

    High-Perception Items

    • Active leaks (even small ones)
    • Pest evidence
    • Items that scare buyers more than they cost

    Offer Credit When:

    Buyer Preference Matters

    • Flooring, paint, fixtures
    • Buyer wants to choose contractor
    • Buyer wants specific materials

    Timing Is Tight

    • Repairs would delay closing
    • Finding contractors is difficult

    Large Projects

    • Major work where quality matters
    • Buyer wants control over the process

    Credit Mechanics

    Credits reduce buyer's closing costs, not purchase price. On a $900,000 sale with $10,000 credit, buyer brings $10,000 less to closing.

    Lender Limits: Most lenders cap credits at 3-6% of purchase price.

    Negotiation Tips

    • Get repair quotes before responding
    • Credits often cost you less than buyer's worst-case estimates
    • Consider the deal as a whole, not each item separately

    Have a question about this?

    I'm happy to walk you through it for your specific situation, no pressure.